Why the Traditional Social Media Agency Model is Dying (And What’s Replacing It in 2024)

TL;DR (Quick Summary)

• The old social media agency model is becoming obsolete. Posting 20 times a month with generic content doesn’t move the needle for businesses anymore.

• Surface-level content won’t drive revenue. Brands that fail to invest in strategic, high-value content will continue to blend in.

• Founder-Led Marketing (FLM) is the future. B2B founders who create engaging, insight-driven content claim 70-90% of their pipeline comes from their personal brand.

• The next wave of social media agencies will focus on building content engines, not just posting. Agencies that help clients create thought leadership, engaging video series, and strategic differentiation will dominate.

• B2B content doesn’t have to be boring-to-boring. The companies that invest in entertaining, insight-driven content will be the ones that win.

  
  

Why Most Social Media Agencies Will Disappear in 2024

The social media agency model that worked a decade ago is on its way out.

AI tools, automation, and in-house content teams have made basic social media management services obsolete.

A decade ago, agencies could charge thousands of dollars for managing a brand’s social presence. Today, businesses have access to:

• AI-powered design tools like Canva and Adobe Firefly that eliminate the need for basic graphic design services.

• Automated social media schedulers that allow teams to manage their own content at scale.

• Paid ad platforms like Meta and LinkedIn that have made it easier for businesses to run ads without an agency.

  
  

Most traditional social media agencies followed the “cookie-cutter” approach:

• Offer the same generic posting schedule to every client.

• Focus on scalability and high-profit margins instead of tailored content strategies.

• Regurgitate industry content instead of helping brands create original thought leadership.

  
  

But B2B buyers have changed.

Today’s prospects don’t just consume content—they self-educate before buying. If your content isn’t helping them make a decision, it’s useless.

Why Founder-Led Marketing (FLM) is the Future

At Extra Sauce Agency, we saw the shift happening in the industry and pivoted.

We realized that the biggest opportunity in B2B marketing today isn’t running ads or posting social media updates—it’s helping founders create content that builds inbound revenue.

Here’s why FLM works:

• Trust drives buying decisions. People trust experts, not faceless brands.

• B2B buyers don’t want to be sold to. They want to follow leaders who share insights, not ads.

• FLM compounds over time. Unlike paid ads, content that positions a founder as an industry leader continues generating leads long after it’s published.

  
  

A B2B founder who posts regularly on LinkedIn, runs a podcast, and shares real industry insights will outperform any brand that relies on outbound sales and paid acquisition alone.

The Data Speaks:

• Founders who leverage personal content claim 70-90% of their pipeline comes from LinkedIn.

• B2B buying cycles are nonlinear. Prospects engage with multiple content touchpoints before making a decision.

• Companies overspending on paid ads are struggling with profitability—while those investing in FLM are building long-term brand equity.

  
  

The New Social Media Agency Model: Content Engines That Drive Revenue

The agencies that will survive in 2024 and beyond are the ones that focus on revenue, not just engagement.

Instead of posting for the sake of posting, modern agencies are helping brands:

1. Create thought leadership content that positions founders as category leaders.

2. Build video content engines that generate inbound demand.

3. Develop high-impact LinkedIn and YouTube content that speaks directly to decision-makers.

4. Turn content into a lead-generation system that nurtures and converts buyers.

   
   

Example:

A SaaS founder could:

• Host a weekly LinkedIn video series or LIVE webinars with other industry leaders and share industry trends and real-life insights.

• Repurpose the content into short-form clips for LinkedIn and Twitter.

• Use their insights to educate prospects instead of cold-selling.

  
  

Instead of generic “thought leadership” posts, the focus is on narrative-driven content that keeps buyers engaged.

Final Thoughts: The Agencies That Will Win in 2024

The agencies that thrive in this new era will be the ones that:

• Help founders create authority-driven content instead of generic posts.

• Focus on pipeline and revenue generation, not just social media engagement.

• Develop unique, insight-driven content strategies that B2B buyers actually care about.

• 
  

B2B doesn’t have to be boring-to-boring. The brands that invest in strategic content today will be the ones dominating their industries tomorrow.

If your company is still relying on outdated agency models, it’s time to evolve—or get left behind.